Thursday, June 28, 2007

Nazis. I HATE Those Guys.

I've actually taken the house off the market. It wasn't going anywhere anyway.

The past week has shown me a different side of the neighborhood- a quiet legion of people here who are black but also have disgust for the behaviors I talked about. Some of my neighbors have approached me about the article, and what resulted was perhaps some of the most REAL and MEANINGFUL conversations about race I've ever been a party to or overheard.

I think but do not know that some people here (Bartlett) don't understand some of the things I feel; I do not get a lot of what they say. I'm not talking about the crack heads and dope dealers or the massive legions of passers-through.

Example: "If you would just talk to your neighbors and make friends, they would watch out for your property and it would be safer".

OK, I get that. But when I asked "Don't you think you should be able to rely on the police to keep the neighborhood safe?" I was met with blank stares. Now, I know that the police can't be everywhere, but I've never lived somewhere where the levels of crime were so acceptable.

It's almost like it's acceptable to have crime as long as you can protect people you know and like from getting victimized. I would think that very touching if the crime here wasn't so rampant.

The fallout here could have been much worse, and this is more of a "clear my head" type of post than any type of grand statement. I'm writing this for me, no one else.

There have been some amusing moments. I had to stop reading comments on the Times site.

It became apparent that a lot of these posters may not have read my article; it would not shock me to know that they hadn’t even finished Rodney’s piece. One allegation made suggested that I have had thefts because I worked as a prostitute and used crack (While I am a –ahem- healthy woman, I haven’t found the need to turn to prostitution, and while I do have my vices, crack has never been one of them). Another accusation suggested that I must have “messed with somebody’s man” (because, as we all know, the appropriate response to infidelity is to steal the adulterer’s lawnmower… I think that’s actually in the Old Testament).

My favorite, though, suggested that Eric Deggans and I had somehow conspired to create this amalgamated media frenzy and sought to divide St. Petersburg in some sort of race war. If you know anything of how a newsroom works and theories about news framing, you may understand that we generally spend our time just try to report news. We do not sit around in some newspaper Bat Cave and scheme to change the world. At best, we can hope to start a dialogue.

These comments, although ignorant, didn’t shock me. But my neighbors did. In my initial article I mentioned a neighbor who brought me food, and the Times’ piece named her: Gail Fisher-Lee. The day Thrash showed her a copy of I Had a Dream, she came to my home. I opened my door, not sure what to expect. She opened her arms and grabbed me in a big bear hug.

“Why didn’t you tell me you felt that way?” she asked.
“Because,” I answered, “I don’t feel that way about you.” What followed was an hour of talking about black, white, and our neighborhood.

Friday morning Wild 98.7 wanted me to take part in their morning show. I declined, and I also chose not to listen. But apparently my neighbors did listen, and at least one of them called in. My neighbor Nicki has a brother who used to stay with her. He called in and, as I understand it, defended me. Nicki came over Friday night and we, too, talked about black, white, and our neighborhood.

And then I got an e-mail from someone identifying themselves as “Yankee James”. He said “keep your chin up…we’ve all been where you’re at.” He also invited me to join a forum at vnnforum.com. Because I’m classically naïve, I didn’t put his screen name together with anything sinister. Because, although I’d had enough of the comments online, stupidity is making the same decisions and expecting different results. I followed the link.

What I read made me physically ill. I won't repeat it here and will not post the link, because the site is populated by freakshows and, well, scary fucking excuses for carbon based life forms.

After I read a line or two and scrolled down a few posts, I looked over at Derek.

"I would rather live here forever than become one of these people," I told him.

Rarely a moment of clarity graces my thoughts. This was one such moment.

This web site was peppered with people I could never become. My struggles with race are far more subtle. One comment I received summed it up intelligently:
“The real question is not whether you're racist - we all are, to some extent - it's what you do with your racist assumptions: whether you actively try to identify them in yourself; whether you struggle with them; whether you let them control your interactions with others or treat people unfairly.” (Carrie M., Brooklyn)

So what do I do now? Do I give in and, as several neighbors said, let the bad things here run me out of my home? Do I, as another friend said, simply stop?

I think the answer lies somewhere in the middle, but I do know this: the support I have received in my neighborhood has made it feel like a community. Look, I didn't take my house off the market because I had any great revelation. I'm the same person with the same struggles. I took the house down because it wasn't gonna sell. But you know what? This past week is the best I've felt about my neighborhood since Derek looked around last December and noticed some stuff was missing from the yard.

I don’t hate black people. But I hate ignorance, violence, and (to paraphrase Indiana Jones), I hate Nazis.

I would rather live in Bartlett Park, with its crime, drugs, and litter, than spend one moment more having Nazi supremacists sympathize with me. I know I have more choices than that, but the past week has given me the perspective that where I sit ain’t so bad, after all.

I’ll take where I am over where "they" are anyday. How horrible it must be to be inside their heads. So as the For Sale sign comes down, I’ll just keep swimming.

4 comments:

Latoya Peterson said...

Cathy -

Please check out the Racialicious.com blog - we discuss all the issues that you seem to want to talk about.

However, I must caution you - we saw your article, read your blog, and I posted an article in response. I am not sure where your head is with all the comments you are receiving.

Either way, please take the time to browse around Racialicious, and discover a community dedicated to talking about race from MULTIPLE perspectives - it goes way beyond black and white.

Vox Populi said...

Well, the questions BEGS asking then> WHY IS IT THAT NOT MUCH NEWS IS REPORTED ??? Just some white woman's 'imagined feeling' that deep down everyone is a racist.

HOW, I ask, IS THAT NEWS, Cathy??

Oh and sorry, we're NOT. (racist) Too truly, your closet racism leaked and that's exactly what everyone should have told you. Just because I consistently stand up to you it makes you all fluffed up.

It would make you look a whole lot better if you could back yourself up with some reality and intelligence rather than snide remarks about the ignorance of others.
It was very revealing when you said how it pissed you off for some kid to wave at his family in the courtroom. (whatever)
And, it might help a LOT if you took the time to actually read (listen) rather than formulating what YOU want to say back instead. That's (as you may have learned in college) active listening.
Obviously you choose to not hear too much about what other people are saying. Could be one of your problems, eh??
It's obvious that you and Eric know each other rather well because right away (within a few SECONDS of me posting to his article) he and 'patrick' (read you) HAHA came on there and told me I was being personal with you. It's so obvious that you're a little clique.
Never mind that you brought your liberal progressive self to MY blog and called me 'sweetie'. LOL. I don't have a problem with you other than you out of hand accused all persons of being racist because YOU are. .
Here's a clue: Instead of 'sitting around the newsroom' how bout yall take yourselves out and report some NEWS???
Seriously.

AND, if you were writing this for YOURself why is it out here on a public blog and NOT in your journal??

Sorry to stand up to you. If you can't take the heat you should get out of the kitchen, eh?

No one is going to call everyone 'closet racists' while I stand by, which YES, is exactly what you did.
You and Tim Fasano. Whew. What's that tell you ??
L O L !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Vox Populi said...

And, by the way, I do not hate anyone, least of all --- YOU.
Don't hate nazis. Pity them. It's not their fault --- someone brought them in to that lifestyle and you would not believe the people high in the clover in Tampa and St Pete who ARE nazis. And, many in the Republican party and yes, that's NOT debatable. It's true.
They are sad and sick people but hate is just more unhealthy to carry than --- empathy.
Yeah, better to be you than them.

Harry Chittenden said...

I didn't know that I was talking to a celebrity the other night when you recommended Randy White to me (so far a good read, BTW). In the time since, I've seen your name in two newspaper articles. Wow!

It's ironic that in this era in which we prize our freedoms so much, there are so many restrictions on what may be said. Your comments were in the sensitives of sensitives. Everyone knows how we ought to think based on generalities; to hell with observable phenomena.

I laughed at Eric Deggan's remark that he and his friends wanted to help you with your writing and your thinking, as if he's offering you re-education a la Cultural Revolution.

You have my respect. You and a few others like you could get a real dialogue going one day.